Most content scores measure how well you filled in the SEO form. This one measures whether the piece is worth publishing — three named dimensions, the sentences that cost you points, the evidence that is missing, and the fix at three sizes.
Every score decomposes into three dimensions a second reviewer could re-check against the same draft. That is the difference between a score you can act on and a score you have to trust.
Answers the question its title sets up, stays inside the scope its format promises, and leaves a reader able to act without a follow-up question.
Relevance, specifics, the conditions that make the advice work, terms defined where they appear, and sentences that say one thing plainly.
Facts a reader might doubt point to where they came from, claims carry the reason they hold, and the piece shows where its results stop holding.
A single number makes you guess what it means. These three answers each map to a decision you were already trying to make.
An answer against a documented pass line, with the dimensions behind it and the sentences that cost you points.
Whether the piece has passages an engine can lift intact — a direct answer near the top of a section, definitions, sourced numbers, stated limits.
A rule pass over specific phrasing habits, each with a suggested action. Not an authorship detector, and it never touches the main score.
Tools like Surfer SEO and Clearscope score how closely a draft resembles the pages currently ranking for one keyword. That is a useful proxy for optimization — and a weak one for outcomes.
26% correlation with rankings in independent testing; Surfer's own benchmark across more than a million SERP entries reports 0.28.
17.5% correlation with rankings in the same independent testing — an editorial convenience, not a prediction.
Measure how a sentence is built, not whether the piece says anything a reader could use. A clean grade can sit on a hollow draft.
A single draft is the cheapest place to catch a quality problem. The identical rubric runs across every indexable URL when you need to decide what to keep, merge or remove.
How a content quality audit works, and the five decisions it ends in →